DOUBLE
REFRACTION
Looking twice at the history of science

Tuesday, October 18, 2016

Words of wisdom from the positivist Ernst Mach

Ernst Mach (1838-1916), positivist
Suppose we have always been constructivists, as I suggested in the last post. And suppose we have too many big pictures, not too few, as I argued in the last post but one. What then? What consequences does this have for the way we do the history of science? Here is one consequence: we should pay more attention to dead historians of science. If they were wise enough to be constructivists, perhaps they were wise in other ways. And if we have not discarded their big pictures, perhaps there were some grains of truth in those big pictures. Consider Ernst Mach’s The Science of Mechanics (1883; mine is the 1960 English edition). Mach was nothing if not a positivist. Some would say he was the original (logical) positivist. But there are many passages in his book that defy the present-day caricature of positivists. Here is a collection of the choicer passages of this kind. Expand post.

8 comments:

  1. Prof Jim Flynn of Otago University (now retired) made exactly the same point (no.8) in a RNZ podcast http://www.radionz.co.nz/search/results?utf8=✓&q=Torchlight&commit=Search that if a person knows only the present, at best they can only be cynical non-participants in the politics of the age, at worst ignorant consumers of political spin. He said people should read more good fiction�� Clare Ryan Selwyn Huts

    ReplyDelete
  2. This book provides a unique perspective on the important physics concept of double refraction. A highly useful resource that must be appreciated by all those who use it.

    ReplyDelete
  3. Swiss replica uk watches, combining elegant style and cutting-edge technology, a variety of styles of Swiss replica a lange sohne watches, the pointer walks between your exclusive taste style.

    ReplyDelete
  4. Die Qualität dieser Replik Nike Schuh ist perfekt, nike billig kaufen es ist sehr angenehm zu tragen, tragen Sie diesen Schuh, wenn Sie reisen, es wird nicht müde. Ich habe diese Seite meinen guten Freunden empfohlen,billig nike Air Max 270 sie sind sehr glücklich, solche billigen Nike-Schuhe kaufen zu können

    ReplyDelete
  5. My boyfriend likes to copy watches. When you buy it back,replica rolex watches this gorgeous replica watch is stunning. The design and function of the watch are very fresh and elegant. The quality is relatively perfect.replica rolex sea dweller watches This replica watch is very special, good quality and very cheap

    ReplyDelete
  6. tanie damskie gucci, łącząc elegancki styl i najnowocześniejszą technologię, różnorodność stylów tanie gucci brelok do kluczy, wskaźnik przechodzi między Twoim ekskluzywnym stylem smaku.

    ReplyDelete
  7. Copiar el reloj es muy bonito, este es un estilo de gama alta.Réplica de relojes Rolex Realmente me gusta este reloj réplica. El servicio de la tienda es muy bueno, la calidad del reloj es muy buena y el precio es muy rentable,Réplica de relojes cosmograph daytona creo que es muy barato, de buena calidad y bajo precio.

    ReplyDelete